WHAT’S THE MATTER WITH HELEN? (1971) * ½
Debbie Reynolds and Shelley Winters leave their small town behind after their sons are convicted of a heinous murder. They soon set up shop in
Screenwriter Henry Farrell also wrote the psychological thrillers with women’s names in the titles, Hush Hush Sweet Charlotte and What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? What’s the Matter with Helen isn’t nearly as cool as those films. The problem is that it’s way too tame for it’s own good. While Charlotte and Baby Jane had a suitably nasty tone, Helen is limp and dull. Unlike Bette Davis and Joan Crawford, Reynolds and Winters do not go over the top. They play things more or less straight and as a result, it isn’t much fun. I did like the part when Shelley killed some rabbits though. (Sixteen years before Glenn Close made it hip.)
Director Curtis (Ruby) Harrington films the proceedings in a workmanlike fashion. Nothing about the film is very memorable but there is a sequence midway through that is positively mind-numbingly terrifying. It’s the scene where Debbie’s students perform onstage. Their routines are all filmed in real time and the intolerable tykes impersonate everyone from Shirley Temple to Mae West. If sitting through a kiddie talent show isn’t the true meaning of horror, I don’t know what is. No wonder Shelley started freaking out backstage and eventually went on a murder spree.